Bagel Fair is a Indianapolis bagel shop where the bagels are hand-rolled and boiled the traditional way. Cream cheese, lox, and bialys round out the offering. Rated 4.7/5 across 353 reviews, it's one of the city's most consistently praised bakeries. Expect Hand-Rolled Bagels, Cream Cheese Varieties, Lox & Schmear, Bialys, Breakfast Sandwiches at the counter.
Take-out New York-style bagels served in a cash-only, family-run strip-mall shop since 1975.
What to Expect
Bagel Fair serves bagels in Indianapolis. At a proper bagel shop, the bagels are hand-rolled and boiled before baking — a process that gives them their characteristic chewy crust and dense interior. Expect cream cheese, lox, and a range of spreads alongside the bagels. The morning rush is the peak time; bagel shops tend to be early-hours operations, and popular varieties sell out.
Bakeries in Indianapolis
From heritage bakeries serving generations of families to a new wave of sourdough and viennoiserie specialists, Indianapolis's 0+ bakeries cover everything that United States's bread culture is known for. Expect strong local traditions alongside internationally influenced technique.
50 Best Bakeries Rating
Google Rating
Based on 353 reviews
Your Rating
Drinks & Specialties
Editorial Recognition
Bagel Fair has earned editorial recognition from 50 Best Bakeries and #458 in United States (#7 in Indianapolis). With a 4.7/5 Google rating from 353 verified reviews, it is among the highest-rated bagel shops in its region.
Location
Some links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more
Contact & Details
📍 1300 E 86th St Suite 19, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA
Opening Hours
Monday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Tuesday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Wednesday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Thursday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Friday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Saturday: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Sunday: 7:00 AM – 1:00 PM
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Bagel Fair specialise in?
Bagel Fair is a bagel shop in Indianapolis, United States, known for Hand-Rolled Bagels, Cream Cheese Varieties, Lox & Schmear, Bialys, and more. The bagel shop format means you can expect a focus on quality baked goods crafted with care.
What is the rating of Bagel Fair?
Bagel Fair holds a Google rating of 4.7/5 based on 353 verified reviews. Our editorial rating is 4.8/5, which factors in consistency, baking quality, and regional standing.
Where is Bagel Fair located?
Bagel Fair is located in Indianapolis, United States. The address is 1300 E 86th St Suite 19, Indianapolis, IN 46240, USA. You can find directions and the exact location on Google Maps.
When is the best time to visit Bagel Fair?
For the freshest selection, visit Bagel Fair shortly after opening — typically between 7am and 10am. Popular items sell through by midday, so early visits give you the best choice. Weekend mornings tend to be busiest.
Does Bagel Fair take orders or reservations?
Most bagel shops operate as walk-in only with counter service. For celebration cakes, custom orders, or large pastry orders, contact Bagel Fair directly through their website to arrange in advance. Some bakeries also offer pre-orders for whole loaves.
How does Bagel Fair compare to other bakeries in Indianapolis?
With a 4.7/5 rating from 353 reviews, Bagel Fair ranks among the highest-rated bakeries in Indianapolis. Our ranking considers Google reviews, editorial recognition, and baking quality to give a balanced picture of the Indianapolis bakery scene.
